About this Event
Almost since its inception, psychoanalysis has contentiously debated the role of personhood in clinical practice, with some schools emphasizing an interpersonal phenomenology that other schools decry for its inattention to an impersonal unconscious. This presentation enters the fray of such debate by considering clinical moments when the analysand’s personhood disturbs the analyst psychically and somatically. Such personhood is not just a self or first person but a third person or thing, which monstrously reminds (monere) the analyst of their originary formlessness and the early deprivations that both analyst and analysand may undergo in the course of development. Inspired by the debates between Sasha Nacht and Jacques Lacan; the philosophies of Georges Bataille, Roberto Esposito, and Frantz Fanon; and the theories of various British (e.g., John Klauber, Donald Winnicott) and French thinkers (e.g., Christian David, Michel de M’Uzan), this presentation challenges the bifurcation of the personal and the impersonal by advancing a clinical notion of the third person, or an ur-person that precedes and exceeds the first person’s separate selfhood. The third person invites us to wonder about moments when analyst and analysand are less mutually identifiable others than asymmetrical functions that unconsciously beget a sometimes-harrowing play between personhood as dispositif and/or necessary illusion and personhood as a monstrosity that both precludes understanding and yet begs to be understood.
Daniel G. Butler, PhD, LMFT is a candidate at the Psychoanalytic Institute of Northern California and a graduate of UC Santa Cruz’s History of Consciousness Program. In addition to serving on the editorial boards of Psychoanalytic Dialogues, Studies in Gender and Sexuality, and JAPA: The Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, Daniel teaches at Access Institute for Psychological Services, the San Francisco Center for Psychoanalysis, and the Northern California Society for Psychoanalytic Psychology. A recipient of several writing awards, Daniel publishes both within and beyond the field of psychoanalysis. His most recent papers, "Say Anything: Noise, Tenderness, and the Rift Between the Saying and the Said," and "When What Preserves Tears Me Apart: The Lytic, the Therapeutic, the Impossible," can be found in Psychoanalytic Dialogues. Although clinical and scholarly work accounts for most of his time, Daniel is also a longstanding participant in art and music subcultures.
Event venue & nearby stays
Pulsion Institute, 321 West 44th Street, New York, United States