Over Easy: A Murder Mystery Dinner

Sat, 01 Nov, 2025 at 06:00 pm UTC-04:00

The Toasted Yolk Cafe (Findlay, OH) | Findlay

Blossom Riley Photography
Publisher/HostBlossom Riley Photography
Over Easy: A Murder Mystery Dinner
Advertisement
🕯️ Over Easy: Murder Mystery Dinner 🕯️
Night one: October 31st SOLD OUT
Night two: November 1st TICKETS AVAILABLE
Something sinister is brewing at Toasted After Dark… and someone didn’t make it past the drink order. Can you crack the case before the toast gets cold?
Join us on Halloween Night, October 31st, for a suspense-filled evening of mystery, scandal, and delicious dining. Guests will step into the story as detectives, suspects, or secret-keepers while unraveling clues in this thrilling murder mystery dinner.
👀 What to Expect:
✨ A fully immersive murder mystery experience
✨ Suspense, twists, and interactive fun
✨ A hauntingly delicious dinner at Toasted After Dark
✨ The perfect Halloween night out with friends
📍 Where: Toasted Yolk Cafe
2020 Tiffin Avenue, Findlay, OH 45840
🕔 When: Friday, October 31st (SOLD OUT) & Saturday, November 1st | 6 PM
💰 Tickets:
$55 per person
$275 per table (seats 6 people)
📞 Reserve Your Seat: Online via the official Over Easy LinkTree.
🎭 Costumes encouraged but not required—just bring your wits and your best detective skills!
Advertisement

Event Venue & Nearby Stays

The Toasted Yolk Cafe (Findlay, OH), 2018 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840-9534, United States

Tickets
Icon
Concerts, fests, parties, meetups - all the happenings, one place.

Discover more events by tags:

Murder-mystery in FindlayHalloween in Findlay

Ask AI if this event suits you:

More Events in Findlay

Falling For Crafts
Sat, 01 Nov at 10:00 am Falling For Crafts

3200 bright road Findlay Ohio

Fall Kitty Cat Yoga
Sat, 01 Nov at 11:00 am Fall Kitty Cat Yoga

The Lavender Hour

Family Day: Perler Bead Pets
Sat, 01 Nov at 02:00 pm Family Day: Perler Bead Pets

206 Broadway St, Findlay, OH, United States, Ohio 45840

Fairy Furniture Making
Sat, 01 Nov at 04:30 pm Fairy Furniture Making

1400 Oakwoods Lane Findlay, Ohio 45840

Chili party
Sat, 01 Nov at 05:00 pm Chili party

State Route 12

Square Dance
Sat, 01 Nov at 05:30 pm Square Dance

750 Bright Rd, Findlay, OH 45840-6946, United States

Wastin' Neon debut at the Findlay Moose Lodge
Sat, 01 Nov at 07:00 pm Wastin' Neon debut at the Findlay Moose Lodge

Findlay Moose Lodge #698

The Kenny Rogers Band
Sat, 01 Nov at 07:00 pm The Kenny Rogers Band

Donnell Theater at Marathon Center For The Performing Arts

Voodoo Horse
Sat, 01 Nov at 08:00 pm Voodoo Horse

Lucky's Tavern and Grill

The Vampire Circus at Marathon Center for the Performing Arts
Sat, 01 Nov at 08:00 pm The Vampire Circus at Marathon Center for the Performing Arts

Marathon Center for the Performing Arts

Alexandria's - Halloween Costume Bash 2025 (Get Your VIP Table Here!!)
Sat, 01 Nov at 08:00 pm Alexandria's - Halloween Costume Bash 2025 (Get Your VIP Table Here!!)

Alexandria's Bar, Restaurant & Event Venue

The Vampire Circus - Findlay
Sun, 02 Nov at 12:00 am The Vampire Circus - Findlay

Marathon Center for the Performing Arts

Findlay is Happening!

Never miss your favorite happenings again!

Explore Findlay Events