Murder Mystery Dinner

Sat Sep 13 2025 at 04:45 pm to 09:30 pm UTC-04:00

Oil Creek and Titusville Railroad | Titusville

Oil Creek and Titusville Railroad
Publisher/HostOil Creek and Titusville Railroad
Murder Mystery Dinner
Advertisement
***This event is sold out***
Mama Mia Mayhem: "Blood Relatives"
Join your favorite big, fat, Italian clan, the Stromboli Family, as they gather for a memorial service to bid farewell to their beloved matriarch Mama Filomena, who has finally taken off to that big pizza parlor in the sky (this time by natural causes…). Their usual raucous rivalry to inherit the family business is finally at an end – – or is it??
Mystery guests and secrets from the past abound as the family that ‘preys’ together, tries to stay together… until one of those loaded cannoli hits its mark! Once again, murder shows its ugly face in the Stromboli family portrait!
Match your wits against the witless and try to solve tonight’s whacking — er, murder, before the spaghetti sauce hits the fan — again!
$80 per person. Reservations required; space is limited.
Call 814-676-1733.
More info and additional dates: https://octrr.org/special-events.../murder-mystery-dinners/
Buffet Menu:
Rolls
Tossed Salad
Broccoli Salad
Fruit Salad
Peas & Carrots
Roasted Red Skinned Potatoes
Baked Chicken
Pot Roast
Various desserts (cakes, pies, cheesecake)
There will be at least 1 Gluten-free option for dessert.
Only other item with gluten are the rolls.
Your evening begins at 4:45 pm at Perry Street Station, 409 S Perry St, Titusville, PA with dinner (caterer TBD). The show, by In All Seriousness, will move to the train for the main acts of the play. Train departs Perry Street Station at 6:15 pm. You will return to the depot at approximately 9:00 pm. Dessert will then be served during the resolution of the show & prizes will be awarded for those that guessed 'whodunit!'
Why not make your evening truly special by staying overnight in an actual Caboose car? Call The Caboose Motel at 814-827-5730 to check availability. With only 21 Cabooses, they book up quickly! Just $95 + tax per night. https://octrr.org/the-caboose-motel/
Advertisement

Event Venue & Nearby Stays

Oil Creek and Titusville Railroad, 409 S Perry St,Titusville, Pennsylvania, United States

Sharing is Caring:

More Events in Titusville

Classic Fantasy Book Club: The Dragonbone Chair by Tad Williams
Fri, 12 Sep at 05:00 pm Classic Fantasy Book Club: The Dragonbone Chair by Tad Williams

105 S Franklin St. Suite 4, Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

"Nathan Merovich" at TIW on Friday, June 20th from 7:00-10:00pm. (NO COVER CHARGE)
Fri, 12 Sep at 07:00 pm "Nathan Merovich" at TIW on Friday, June 20th from 7:00-10:00pm. (NO COVER CHARGE)

315 S. Franklin Street, 16354

Fall Gas Up
Sat, 13 Sep at 09:00 am Fall Gas Up

202 Museum Ln, Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

YMCA Pickleball Tournament - Regional Golden Ticket Qualifier
Sat, 13 Sep at 10:00 am YMCA Pickleball Tournament - Regional Golden Ticket Qualifier

Ed Myer Complex

cats and dogs grand opening
Sat, 13 Sep at 01:00 pm cats and dogs grand opening

The Mercantile

Karaoke & Cocktails with Ham & Brian!
Sat, 13 Sep at 08:00 pm Karaoke & Cocktails with Ham & Brian!

221 S Monroe St , Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

Book Hedgehogs
Mon, 15 Sep at 05:30 pm Book Hedgehogs

213 N Franklin St, Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

Free Trivia in The Pub - Theme: Monty Python
Wed, 17 Sep at 07:00 pm Free Trivia in The Pub - Theme: Monty Python

221 S Monroe St , Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

Romantasy Book Club: Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry
Fri, 19 Sep at 05:00 pm Romantasy Book Club: Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry

105 S Franklin St. Suite 4, Titusville, PA, United States, Pennsylvania 16354

Kids Night Out
Fri, 19 Sep at 05:00 pm Kids Night Out

Titusville YMCA, PA

Titusville is Happening!

Never miss your favorite happenings again!

Explore Titusville Events