Advertisement
The Ambivalence of Progress: a PhD and Postdoc Workshop7-8 November 2024
City Museum of Ljubljana
more info: zgodovina.ff.uni-lj.si/dvoumnost-napredka-ambivalence-progress
PDF of the programme: zgodovina.ff.uni-lj.si/sites/default/files/documents/programme_-_the_ambivalence_of_progress.pdf
Progress is an intricate notion. On the one hand, contemporary societies seem to be better off than societies of the past by many indications: modern economic growth is unprecedented, life expectancy is higher than it’s ever been, new technologies have enabled possibilities that previous generations could only dream of, wars between great powers have been on the decline, etc. All this would seem to naturally inspire optimism about the nature of historical development. One can mention Steven Pinker as the recent outstanding promoter of this view.
There are, however, many objections that can be raised. Economic expansion resulted in an unprecedented destruction of the environment, which is certain to entail major political and social consequences in the 21st century. The level of inequality both between and within countries is still very high and has been growing in the neoliberal period, which points to the fact that many countries and social groups have been excluded from the fruits of progress. Technological advancements may have opened up new possibilities, but they also unleashed new problems, including new kinds of violence and warfare. There is furthermore the inherent power disparity and exploitative nature of class relations in capitalism, which profoundly affects most people’s everyday life. Progress has many flip sides.
The dilemma is not new. While it was lurking in the background for most of human history, the notion of progress came to the fore in the age of enlightenment and was one of the defining ideas of the 19th century, informing the ruling ideologies. However, this faith in progress came to a halt in the face of the two world wars and the rise of totalitarian regimes in the first half of the 20th century. After its resumption in the post-war period, another climax of the belief in progress was the period of the 1990s, when history itself was famously proclaimed to be at an end. This optimism was once again short-lived, since the events of 9/11, the 2008 financial crisis and the rise of new populisms complicated any simple historical narrative. Hence it seems that the idea of progress itself tends to have a cyclical – rather than a progressive – history.
These predicaments also take on a specific flavour in the local Slovenian context. While the older historiography, which understood Slovenian history as a grand march toward national independence, has been largely superseded, most contemporary historians would probably agree that the falling apart of Yugoslavia and the transition to liberal democracy was a welcome development. Leftwing critics, on the other hand, point to the price that was paid for this advance: the steep rise of precarious work, the unequal distribution of wealth, the corrosion of social welfare, etc. The transition to capitalism and liberal democracy resulted in a number of negative developments, which one has to take into account in understanding the history of Slovenia since its independence.
All this suggests that progress is an ambivalent and multi-faceted notion that should be used with a great deal of caution and reflection. How, then, should we think about the major changes that happened with the onset of modernity? How was progress conceptualized in different historical epochs? To what extent did notions of progress differ between different regions and different social groups, and what can we learn from such comparisons? How should we understand the transitions between different political regimes, particularly in the 20th century?
These are some of the topics that are going to be discussed at the PhD and Postdoc Workshop ‘The Ambivalence of Progress’.
The workshop is organized by the Department of History at the Faculty of Arts, University of Ljubljana
Advertisement
Event Venue & Nearby Stays
Mestni muzej Ljubljana, Gosposka ulica 15, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenija,Ljubljana, Slovenia
